Rolf Kreitel
Consultant · Trainer · Coach
Leadership • Ethics • Sustainability
Ethics isn’t extra. It’s the core.

360° Feedback: Done Right or Not at All
Superficial ratings and broken trust ruin the exercise. Managed well, it becomes a lever for leadership growth and cultural change.
What 360° Feedback Really Means
360° feedback is often misunderstood as a simple survey.
In reality, it is an effective tool for leadership and cultural development – if designed and managed with care.
Leaders receive feedback from every direction: managers, peers, and team members, alongside their own self-assessment.
This creates a fuller picture of how they lead, where they succeed, and where change is needed.
Done right, 360° feedback does more than evaluate. It builds trust, sparks conversations about leadership and communication, and turns data into a foundation for growth.
Closing the Feedback Gap
Leaders often hear only numbers and reports. 360° feedback adds the missing voices – giving context, nuance, and meaning to performance data.

Driving Cultural Change
Feedback becomes democratic: not just top-down, but shared across the organization. This shift builds trust, responsibility, and collaboration.
Greater Objectivity
Clear criteria replace gut feeling. Structured feedback ensures leadership is assessed against consistent standards, not personal bias.

Empowering Employees
Team members don’t just follow – they contribute to leadership development. Their perspective shapes growth and strengthens ownership.
The Science Behind 360° Feedback

Richard Lepsinger & Anntoinette D. Lucia (2009). The Art and Science of 360° Feedback, 2nd edition. Pfeiffer Publishing.
This widely cited book is a standard reference in leadership development, highlighting how 360° feedback strengthens both individual leaders and organizational culture.
Key takeaways from the book:
-
Multi-perspective insight: Feedback from managers, peers, and employees creates a holistic picture of leadership effectiveness
-
Development over evaluation: 360° feedback is most powerful when used to grow leaders, not just rate them
-
Culture of dialogue: Feedback fosters openness, accountability, and shared responsibility
-
Sustainability: Embedding 360° processes builds long-term trust and leadership capacity across the organization
My own learning journey:
For me, this book has been more than a reference – it has been an inspiration. Written by seasoned coaches and consultants, it distills decades of practical experience with 360° feedback. The richness of real-world case studies not only deepened my understanding but also guided me in shaping my own implementations.
It showed me how feedback, when thoughtfully designed, becomes both a leadership development tool and a cultural transformation driver.
Designing 360° Feedback That Fits Your Culture
360° feedback only works if the questions reflect your leadership reality.
That’s why I don’t apply generic templates.
Together with your management and HR, I design a feedback catalog that captures observable behaviors – anchored in your leadership culture, values, and development priorities.

My 4-step process to design 360° feedback that fits your culture.
Six Months to Meaningful Leadership Insights
Many organizations try 360° feedback – few succeed.
Why?
Because ratings stay superficial, results get lost in reports, or trust breaks down when confidentiality is breached.
My approach avoids these pitfalls: a six-month, tightly managed process that actually changes behavior. Not a survey exercise. Not another report in a drawer.
At its best, it provokes real conversations about leadership and communication, turns feedback into clear coaching profiles, and gives employees responses they can recognize in their daily work.
That’s when trust starts to grow.

Pre-Implementation
6–8 weeks
-
Align with leadership & HR
-
Define roles & timelines
-
Draft tailored questionnaires

Launch
2 weeks
-
Inform all participants
-
Select & brief raters
-
Clarify expectations

Implementation
6 weeks
-
Open the survey
-
Send invitations & reminders
-
Monitor participation

Analysis & Reporting
6 weeks
-
Analyze results
-
Generate clear reports
-
Highlight key insights

Feedback Delivery
4 - 6 weeks
-
Individual feedback sessions
-
Results translated into leadership profiles (e.g. Coaching Manager, Performance Driver)
-
Coaching plans tailored to growth potential